Skip to main content

Propane tank exchange vs refill which is better for you? Fuel Life Simply

By February 1, 2021October 19th, 2022No Comments

I also considered 30, 33, 40, 60, and 100 pound cylinders, to avoid refilling as often. I found that new 30 or 33 lb cylinders are at least double the price of a 20 lb, and finding lightly used ones on Craigslist wasn’t happening. Fueling your outdoor fun has never been easier with Blue Rhino Tank Exchange Program. It’s a convenient way to replenish your propane tank, from grills to patio heaters. Plus, right now you can save money with this mail-in rebate. Refilling your propane tank can be quick and effortless as well.

My problems from the previous year had been caused from those piece of shi+ Northern heaters, which were defective from the very first day they arrived. I bought three of them, and it seems strange they were ALL defective. I highly recommend you don’t buy your heaters through the mail from Northern.

If you only have one tank for your grill, you probably do not want to have it run completely out before exchanging or refilling. Many a family BBQ has been interrupted by a quick trip to get more propane. The tank exchange program offered by the company is ultra-easy to participate in. Some parks have stopped refilling bottles, preferring the high profit of exchanging either BR or Amerigas.

The fire is clean – no smoke and there is no clean up. Just turn off the gas tank and head inside for the evening. No worry about hot ashes or accidental fires. In case you read or heard that Blue Rhino tanks cannot be refilled by other propane dealers, that apparently is no longer true. It used to be that you could not take a Blue Rhino tank to a bulk re-filler because Blue Rhino used a proprietary valve.

My advice is to get a quality tank with a meter gauge and refill yourself, as needed. In colder climates, suppliers may be reluctant to fill the tank up to capacity. If this is the case, you can expect to pay less money for what people may advertise as a full tank. Hence, this location may record a full tank as less than the standard full designation (4.7 gallons).

  • When I took the tank back to exchange it, they happily complied and I’ve been happy ever since.
  • The 20# tank is now working in my brand new gas grill.
  • The retail store will allow you to pick the Blue Rhino tank you want.

And I knew ahead of time it wasn’t a good deal. I took a deep dive into propane tank capacities and how to weigh your tank to determine how much propane is left. Also at the beginning of that post, is the picture below, showing three 20# in the foreground. It requires you to invert the 20lb cylinder to have liquid propane flow to the 1 lb cylinder.

The most common use of propane gas is for cooking food, but there are numerous uses for this type of gas. Do not attempt to repair a damaged tank or valve; it’s not worth the few dollars worth of savings. The size of the propane tank you need depends on the size of your home. The Blue Rhino propane tank size will vary from 1lb up to 420lb.

This would be less of an issue if the relief value were bleeding to outside air. Overall, propane and the tanks are very safe. Propane itself is very safe because it’s non-toxic. We provide a safe experience with all our equipment and moving experiences. When you bring your tank for a refill, we offer a free inspection of your tank to check for any rust, dents, or any issue with the valve.

Product Q & A

I am not sure how road tax is calculated on bi-fuel vehicles, or those that warm up on gasoline and switch to propane automatically. Perhaps gasoline road tax is refunded altogether when propane purchase volume correlates with mileage driven. The Federal Trade Commission issued an administrative complaint against Ferrellgas Partners, L.P and Ferrellgas, L.P. And UGI Corporation and AmeriGas Partners, L.P. Take care of the tank and keep it from getting wet and it should last. As long as it has the threads on the outside of the valve it should be fillable.

how much does blue rhino cost

OPDs were introduced because so many unqualified and/or negligent people were overfilling tanks, which can be very dangerous to say the least. It is well know they have proprietary fill valves designed to screw customers into being captive. The stations that charge based on temperature correct gallons or weight are being fair.

Lowe’s Blue Rhino Propane Tank Exchange Only $13.97 – Regular Price $19.97

1- Refilling may be done at many service stations, garden/nursery center, etc. This is likely to be closer to your home than an exchange location like blue rhino. If you are using a medium-sized barbecue or grill, a 20 lb propane tank will last your about hours. If you are operating a large grill, then you can expect your 20 lb propane cylinder to last about 10 hours. If you are frequently purchasing propane, then buying your own tank makes a lot of financial sense.

At $3.45 per gallon, it would cost $16.22 to fill an empty tank. However, a lot of places have a 5 gallon minimum, so they will charge $17.25 to fill a partially empty 20# tank. In the first example, bulk is $3.75 cheaper than the Blue Rhino, and if there is a minimum charge it is still $2.72 cheaper to refill your tank. Given that I had three tanks, the exchange cost for me was $11.25 more than if I had taken three tanks to the U-Haul store less than a mile away. A store or company may try to tell you that the 20 lb cylinder can only hold 15 pounds because they cannot be filled all the way up due to safety.

Find a Ferrellgas or Blue Rhino location near you

The cost and inconvenience of re-certifying almost always outweighs the price of a new tank. For the last 7 years I had my trusty Weber grill hooked into a 500 gallon underground tank at the house in Taylors. When I moved earlier this year to an all-electric house I had to switch back to a standard 20 lb BBQ grill tank.

  • My local hardware charges $20 exchange, which works out to $5.67 per gallon, which is over twice the refill price.
  • I don’t even use Rhino or any one else’s tanks, that is why I have two tanks under the barbecue.
  • That makes propane .56 times as dens as water, not .43 times as dense.
  • You will pay less per gallon on propane, and you will pay less to refill your tank if you have propane left in the tank when you go to refill it.
  • The tank exchange program offered by the company is ultra-easy to participate in.
  • Prices, promotions, styles, and availability may vary.

The only thing blue rhino is good for is exchanging your old cylinders for new ones. That’s like filling a gallon paint can with 96 ounces then saying, “read the label” when they get caught. Some containers have implied specific volumes or weights, just like paint and propane.

Even the NACO campground in Birch Bay WA was only 2.69 per gallon. Exchange cabinets companies have been short filling since the concept started. I always thought the tank swaps bee token scam were a ripoff, along the pre-set refill price where they charge you for a full bottle, regardless of how much they put in. Blue Rhino has been short filling since forever.

How much does a Blue Rhino propane tank cost?

Delivery is limited to the member’s residence, which must be within the local Participating Beta Test Program Retailer’s delivery service area. You may receive exclusive specials, valuable coupons, advance sale notices and new product alerts. Prices were current at the time of posting.

This means summer, spring, summer, or fall. We are always on the lookout for good deals on propane. Summer cuisine tastes equally good during winter. We often grill when there is snow on the ground.

For price comparisons between per gallon and per tank charges, consider that an empty 20# tank will hold about 4.6 to 4.7 gallons. To keep the math simple consider 5 gallons times the per gallon price and subtract about a dollar. In very cold winter climates, like Canada, there may be more concern/rules about filling a tank to a complete 20 lbs. With enough of a temperature increase, the tank’s pressure relief value will release a bit of gas.

Leave a Reply